Both very good choices. I'd say chances are quite high that the S4 Mini will be available first.
-
Save 15% on ALL SFF Network merch, until Dec 31st! Use code SFF2024 at checkout. Click here!
Yes, I think even the last few ones are gone now, but @Josh | NFC is working hard to bring it back. He was selling those cases at a loss, so he has to find a way to at least break even if he wants to sustain that. I'm sure he'll manage it, but it could take a while.
Ouch. He did have a lot of premium industrial quality though. I would have spurged on it if it has offered an internal PSU. I'm a big fan of his industrial look.
The internal PSU from the Brevis is a plus if you are in the contra group about the external brick concept, although people are trying to fit a few hundred watts of power inside an S4 Mini too. I can't wait for the final form of the Brevis !
You mean like this? Yeah it's looking fabulous, the powdercoating quality is absolutely top notch as well.
You and me both. I've played with the idea of replacing the aluminium sidepanels with frosted acrylic, that could look super dope. I think I'm at a point where I need to learn how to properly render with 3DSmax to try out different ideas for the outer shell and get a reasonably well idea of what it will actually look like.
Small poll:
A GPU is not the only thing one might want to put into the GPU compartment, and I've recently made a change to allow for a fan swap. What would you put there?
A GPU is not the only thing one might want to put into the GPU compartment, and I've recently made a change to allow for a fan swap. What would you put there?
This project made me create an account here. It just looks awesome. Two thumbs up!
Couple of questions tho, probably you've already answered it somewhere but I couldn't find it: Why didn't you choose to arrange the motherboard in between the GPU and PSU as shown below (sorry for the bad illustrations)
Also, have you explored using Athena Power AP-MFATX50P8 500W PSU ? It's nice to have 500W of power for future high end but tiny cards with HBM.
I know that these PSU are loud. But you can remove the stock fan and put a Noctua A-Series NF-A4x10 40mm in the PSU.
Couple of questions tho, probably you've already answered it somewhere but I couldn't find it: Why didn't you choose to arrange the motherboard in between the GPU and PSU as shown below (sorry for the bad illustrations)
Also, have you explored using Athena Power AP-MFATX50P8 500W PSU ? It's nice to have 500W of power for future high end but tiny cards with HBM.
I know that these PSU are loud. But you can remove the stock fan and put a Noctua A-Series NF-A4x10 40mm in the PSU.
Last edited:
Welcome !
HBM2 cards are expected to require less power than both GDDR5 and GDDR5X, so you wouldn't need a bigger PSU just for that.
That 40x10mm Noctua fan would not suffice most likely, since it would be replacing a 40x20mm from what I can tell, probably going to fall short on pressure. The picture is of a 80mm fan I'm guessing, this is the 40x10mm:
HBM2 cards are expected to require less power than both GDDR5 and GDDR5X, so you wouldn't need a bigger PSU just for that.
That 40x10mm Noctua fan would not suffice most likely, since it would be replacing a 40x20mm from what I can tell, probably going to fall short on pressure. The picture is of a 80mm fan I'm guessing, this is the 40x10mm:
It's a pretty well known fact around here that the Athena supplies are terrible. They often don't meet their advertised wattage, have quality control issues, etc. It's the whole reason we're trying to crowdsource an FSP or Seasonic 500W unit through the community.
This project made me create an account here. It just looks awesome. Two thumbs up!
Couple of questions tho, probably you've already answered it somewhere but I couldn't find it: Why didn't you choose to arrange the motherboard in between the GPU and PSU as shown below (sorry for the bad illustrations)
Those are all great questions, sorry it took me so long to reply.
First off the GPU position. First off, using a solid riser like you showed (your illustration are mirrored left-to-right, BTW) requires the GPU to intake air from the opposite side of the case to the CPU. So if you put the case flat on the table or hang it against the wall, you need a lot more space in order to get sufficient airflow and minimise recirculating air. Additionally, it allows the case to be placed upside down underneath a monitor without the monitors stand blocking any intakes.
So now, I could use a short flexible riser like HDPLEX uses in the H5 chassis to solve that problem, but then the problem of exhaust remains. You'd have two options: Either place the PSU next to the mainboard, as you did, or place it next to the GPU. Placing it next to the mainboard is hardly a good idea as that would block most exhaust air from the CPU cooler. You'd have to remove the motherboards I/O shield to prevent the CPU fan from recycling air, which is hardly an ideal solution. It will still be required for some ASUS boards that have tall daughterboards on the top edge, but ideally it should be avoided when possible.
So the other option is to place the PSU next to the GPU. While GPUs are designed towards rear exhaust more, quite a few have suboptimal cooler designs that just exhaust air everywhere. So the GPU should have a side exhaust as well.
Putting the PSU in the middle is the ideal solution in terms of airflow as the PSU can only intake from the front and only exhaust at the back. It is the only component that doesn't have a benefit from being located near a side exhaust.
So the airflow concept is all air comes from one large panel, and is exhausted towards the back and the two sides.
Also, have you explored using Athena Power AP-MFATX50P8 500W PSU ? It's nice to have 500W of power for future high end but tiny cards with HBM.
Personally, I didn't, but @Hahutzy did, and he found that the Athena unit isn't even close to being able to suppy 500W, so it would be a bad choice to include. Read more in the Wiki-Article and the linked sources. AthenaPower in general is well-known for sub-par quality, as @ilovelampshade said.
A much better choice would be the FSP500-50FSPT, which you might already know about. If not, be sure to follow the link and fill out the survey if you're interested.
I know that these PSU are loud. But you can remove the stock fan and put a Noctua A-Series NF-A4x10 40mm in the PSU.
As @Phuncz mentioned, this fan is way to weak for a PSU of this caliber. To put it into numbers, the airflow of the NF-A4 is 8.2m³/h. The FSP500-50FSPT, which is the most efficient FlexATX PSU on the market today, needs 19.54m³/h at full load. So even with two of these fans next to each other, the PSU would not be able to supply it's maximum load. If you only wanted to pull like 100W, it might not be a problem, but at that point the stock fan will be whisper quiet already.
If you've got any more questions, feel free to ask.
On the topic of the solid angled riser layout:
Yea the main downside is the 2-side intake.
The upside is you can build a system that's under 3L (external PSU). I've drawn up something with that layout in the past few weeks because I'm waiting for new pcie cables to arrive for XS and can't really work on it atm.
Yea the main downside is the 2-side intake.
The upside is you can build a system that's under 3L (external PSU). I've drawn up something with that layout in the past few weeks because I'm waiting for new pcie cables to arrive for XS and can't really work on it atm.
This project made me create an account here. It just looks awesome. Two thumbs up!
Couple of questions tho, probably you've already answered it somewhere but I couldn't find it: Why didn't you choose to arrange the motherboard in between the GPU and PSU as shown below (sorry for the bad illustrations)
QUOTE]
What motherboard is that???!???!????x10 I would love to use one with a reverse/upsidedown/backwards layout like that! 0_o it is breaking my brain
The closest you're going to get is one of these boards but good luck finding one to buy: https://smallformfactor.net/forum/threads/asus-b85m-view-paker.82/
Ohhh the things mini-STX could've been with an angled connector like that. *sobs*
haha. I'm bad at 3D modelling
. BTW, I follow your awesome YouTube channel. I'm the user that suggested using a Vicor small form factor ADC-DC converter inside S4 Mini to get rid of the external power brick.
Those are all great questions, sorry it took me so long to reply.
First off the GPU position. First off, using a solid riser like you showed (your illustration are mirrored left-to-right, BTW) requires the GPU to intake air from the opposite side of the case to the CPU. So if you put the case flat on the table or hang it against the wall, you need a lot more space in order to get sufficient airflow and minimise recirculating air. Additionally, it allows the case to be placed upside down underneath a monitor without the monitors stand blocking any intakes.
So now, I could use a short flexible riser like HDPLEX uses in the H5 chassis to solve that problem, but then the problem of exhaust remains. You'd have two options: Either place the PSU next to the mainboard, as you did, or place it next to the GPU. Placing it next to the mainboard is hardly a good idea as that would block most exhaust air from the CPU cooler. You'd have to remove the motherboards I/O shield to prevent the CPU fan from recycling air, which is hardly an ideal solution. It will still be required for some ASUS boards that have tall daughterboards on the top edge, but ideally it should be avoided when possible.
So the other option is to place the PSU next to the GPU. While GPUs are designed towards rear exhaust more, quite a few have suboptimal cooler designs that just exhaust air everywhere. So the GPU should have a side exhaust as well.
Putting the PSU in the middle is the ideal solution in terms of airflow as the PSU can only intake from the front and only exhaust at the back. It is the only component that doesn't have a benefit from being located near a side exhaust.
So the airflow concept is all air comes from one large panel, and is exhausted towards the back and the two sides.
If you've got any more questions, feel free to ask.
Thanks. I didn't think about the horizontal placement.
On the power supply, what would be the best choice to power a GTX 1070 mini ?
haha. I'm bad at 3D modelling
BTW, I follow your awesome YouTube channel. I'm the user that suggested using a Vicor small form factor ADC-DC converter inside S4 Mini to get rid of the external power brick.
Were you referring to this http://www.vicorpower.com/ac-dc/converters/isolated-ac-dc-converter-pfc ?
Or perhaps this http://www.vicorpower.com/products?productType=cfg&productKey=V24A28C500BL ?
That would be nice to put in a chassis especially if you want it to be compact.
Similar threads
