• Save 15% on ALL SFF Network merch, until Dec 31st! Use code SFF2024 at checkout. Click here!

DAN C4-SFX

absolutelyderek

Chassis Packer
Dec 25, 2020
13
17
derekgates.us

Hey @dondan , do i need to have an 18mm VLP memory to use a second fan on D12L or a normal 32mm RAM without the heatsink would work? Thanks!


I personally went with G Skill Flare for my Ryzen: https://www.gskill.com/product/165/396/1665021601/F5-5200J3636C16GX2-FX5

It is 33mm which makes it 1mm taller than what Dan has recommended:

dondan said:
I check it again it it look like it will also fit with LP-Ram (32mm height) if you do not use the aio bracket. So VLP (18mm height) is only required for second fan if you like to also use the aio bracket with a extra 140mm side mounted fan.



He is exactly right; 32mm is the max. My case pokes out a tiny bit (the 1mm) but isn't enough to bother me to find lower profile RAM or remove heatsinks.
 

Nichronos

SFF Lingo Aficionado
Jun 22, 2018
131
66
I personally went with G Skill Flare for my Ryzen: https://www.gskill.com/product/165/396/1665021601/F5-5200J3636C16GX2-FX5

It is 33mm which makes it 1mm taller than what Dan has recommended:





He is exactly right; 32mm is the max. My case pokes out a tiny bit (the 1mm) but isn't enough to bother me to find lower profile RAM or remove heatsinks.

Many thanks for the reply, i missed the original Dan message regarding this and its quite a hassle scrolling 200 pages (4000 posts) to find this exact information.
Cheers!
 
  • Like
Reactions: absolutelyderek

amar92

Chassis Packer
Feb 20, 2024
13
24
I completely understand that Dan has a life too, and that its a lot of work to design, manufacture and bring a case to market, although we have to be honest, he put out a few cases already and knows with whom to work with etc... the lack of communication is the problem. He's been online here on multiple occasions and didn't reply to this thread in months, although we had a lot of suggestions and questions....

Looking forward to an update, although I'm very sure he's waiting to see how big the RTX 50 Generation of cards is gonna be, so I expect the case approx Summer 2025.
 

hrh_ginsterbusch

King of Cable Management
Silver Supporter
Nov 18, 2021
759
297
wp-devil.com
I completely understand that Dan has a life too, and that its a lot of work to design, manufacture and bring a case to market, although we have to be honest, he put out a few cases already and knows with whom to work with etc... the lack of communication is the problem. He's been online here on multiple occasions and didn't reply to this thread in months, although we had a lot of suggestions and questions....

Looking forward to an update, although I'm very sure he's waiting to see how big the RTX 50 Generation of cards is gonna be, so I expect the case approx Summer 2025.
I wonder if its PDA? That not a real diagnosis, but .. you know, a lot of us geeks are also somewhere located in the neurodivergent .. spectrum, for lack of better words?

On that note, dear @dondan - yes, life and everything, esp. nerds in a specialized forum, can be VERY demanding. BUT you always can ask for .. help, you know? If juggling tasks is too much at the very moment in life, redirection and dropping tasks onto others is a possibility, and very stress-reducing :)

Yeah, I am aware thats not an easy thing to do. And also, that people have different forms of communication. But well, at the end of the day, we here are NOT angry customers DEMANDING you to show at at X 'o'clock on Day Y with a specific solution to problem Z - I think most of us are very happy to help you out in any tasks that you might find overwhelming, despite the fact you want it to be done right.

On "do it right": Well, I think with all the people gathered here, there are quite a few who are insanely precise and meticolous however thats spelled, hyperfixate on a lot of details, and rake their brains about this detail or another feature that just doesnt sit right with them.

So, dont isolate and compress, expand and connect! :)👋

cu, w0lf.
 

Covuk

Average Stuffer
Jun 13, 2023
76
82
"Taps the sign"

 

Xan-Z

Minimal Tinkerer
New User
Aug 18, 2019
3
2
I mean i understand the dilemma between 13.37L (ITX + 3Slot GPU up to 330mm) or 15.4L (ITX/mATX + 4.5 Slot GPU up to 340mm.

13.37L: risky, as maybe this don’t fit current AND next gen GPU’s. And even in the case next gen will be more compact, a lot of people who already has current gpu models won’t be able to use the 13.37L model, so a lot of potential customers are out of the purchase. If DAN launches this model and don’t fit next gen gpus this case would be dead. So the option for this case is to wait until oficial sizing of new gpus, launching the 13.37L model but letting out a lot of people who already as big-current gen-gpu’s

15.4L: safest, will fit current and new gpus, matx boards. Two liters more bur the safest option, this could launch at anytime (no need to wait for next gpu dimensions). A lot of potential customers as:
A) is the most voted option in the poll
B) a lot of people can buy it for new and old builds (case switch) nobody is out in this model.

I think going 15.4L is safer for current market state as it covers current and future hardware 100%. The other option is to wait and delay until 5000 series BUT at 13.37L 330mm 3slots a lot of current big gpus owners are out.


Those are my toughts
 
  • Like
Reactions: Facteur and amar92

Facteur

Caliper Novice
Feb 6, 2024
25
33
I mean i understand the dilemma between 13.37L (ITX + 3Slot GPU up to 330mm) or 15.4L (ITX/mATX + 4.5 Slot GPU up to 340mm.
Well, the way you present the situation, there's no dilemma 😅
It's mATX all the way.

Ideally, Dan would release the mATX design ASAP, and then in 2025 the ITX one.
It's no small work, but both designs are pretty much ready from what I gather...
 

Sift5262

Case Bender
New User
Sep 7, 2024
2
7
I think gpu compatibility is what should determine the next Dan C4, not m.atx support. If the 13.37L Dan C4 fits the next 5000 series, 13.37L would be amazing. No point to have a 15.4L model if the smaller one has good enough gpu compatibility. In the other hand, if the new gpus are still massive, no point to have a 13.37L case with bad gpu compatibility.

Matx support would he in 2nd place. If new gpus are very big, then the choice would be 15.4liters Dan C4 with matx support mainly because gpu clearance. But if they are smaller, it’s not worth to add 2liters more just for matx support.

A lot of builders are waiting to the new 9000x3ds and rtx 5000 so i wouldn’t mind to wait a few months more to see if we can get the smaller one, as i suppose it’s the size that fits the “purpose” of dan cases designs: smallest possible, with the best compability. 13.37L case with good gpu support would be unique, as we already have 15-16-17L cases with 4slot+matx mb. But we don’t have any under 14L case with good high end hardware support. We only can get that “unique case” if we wait for the new releases… and i suppose the job with the 13.37L case is already done and ready for production, so if new cards fits, then is a green light for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rfarmer

amar92

Chassis Packer
Feb 20, 2024
13
24
Imagine releasing two things, C4 v2 and making it 13 L, and a C4 v2 XL = The same but support for mATX, 4,4 slot gpu, 155-160 CPU Cooler height and making it something like 17-18 L.

Hmmm maybe not a bad idea 😅

The people can choose, and I'm sure both would be sold out.

McPrue Apollo S 3.0 offers something like that almost, plus you can put a fan in front which I find great. But costs like 400+ Euro.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hrh_ginsterbusch

Quigonjinn

Trash Compacter
May 8, 2023
43
29
*checks back after some months*
Ah, he still doesn't reply, amazing.

I honestly wonder how some of you guys still haven't come to the conclusion that this project might not be worth your time any more 😞
Eh, it’s not like he has taken pre-orders or money and then gone dark. He’s not obligated to provide a case in a certain time frame.

Last I heard he has had a newborn and those come with quite a bit of workload. Also we have no idea if that’s the only change in their life, could be other issues that required their focus and not allow development of a niche case.

Some of us don’t mind waiting and watching what comes out, it’s no big deal as there are alternatives nowadays. SFF is in its golden age.
 

Sift5262

Case Bender
New User
Sep 7, 2024
2
7
I think gpu compatibility is what should determine the next Dan C4, not m.atx support. If the 13.37L Dan C4 fits the next 5000 series, 13.37L would be amazing. No point to have a 15.4L model if the smaller one has good enough gpu compatibility. In the other hand, if the new gpus are still massive, no point to have a 13.37L case with bad gpu compatibility.

Matx support would he in 2nd place. If new gpus are very big, then the choice would be 15.4liters Dan C4 with matx support mainly because gpu clearance. But if they are smaller, it’s not worth to add 2liters more just for matx support.

A lot of builders are waiting to the new 9000x3ds and rtx 5000 so i wouldn’t mind to wait a few months more to see if we can get the smaller one, as i suppose it’s the size that fits the “purpose” of dan cases designs: smallest possible, with the best compability. 13.37L case with good gpu support would be unique, as we already have 15-16-17L cases with 4slot+matx mb. But we don’t have any under 14L case with good high end hardware support. We only can get that “unique case” if we wait for the new releases… and i suppose the job with the 13.37L case is already done and ready for production, so if new cards fits, then is a green light for me

Want to add that MAYBE, in the end, some RTX5000 fits in the 13.37L, but how many of them? I remember at the time in the Dan C4 13.37L some 4080 and 4090 could fit, but only FE models (low stock, higher price, scalping,
lower availability) + other cheap models like MSI VENTUS (worse temps etc) so DAN made a poll between 13.37L with lower gpu compatibility or the 14.7L model, the second one won and got released. What i want to say is that it doesn’t matter if the 13.37L model could fit some 5080/5090, it should fit most of them or we would be in the same situation than in the 4000 series.

14.5L, which is smaller than the v1 but with matx support + amazing GPU compatibility is a BANGER case. Everybody would be happy, people who wanted the v1 and newcomers. Plus people who already have big gpus and want a C4 case, could swap cases without problems in the 14.5L model.
 

amar92

Chassis Packer
Feb 20, 2024
13
24
Exactly Sift, completely agree.

What I would add is 15 mm more width to accommodate a 155-160 CPU Cooler. That could probably add the option to install a 120mm fan in the back, and maybe one in the front like in the McPrue Apollo S v3.0

That would be the perfect case for me, personally.

Right now I'm running a 7950X3D and RTX 4090 and my temps are pretty amazing in the C4 v1.

I have to admit that I dream about the same case but being able to fit something like the upcoming Thermalright Royal Pretor 130..

Just imagine it :

ITX/MATX, CPU Cooler 155-160mm, 3 Slot GPU + 140x25 Fans, 120mm rear plus eventually a 120mm front (would have to be a front grille or mesh in the front...

All in about 17,5L, would just have to add about 1,5-2 cm in all directions.

Yes it would be a bit bigger, but would we really notice it that much? It isn't 25-30 L..

Wouldn't that be the perfect no compromise SFF case?

I was even thinking of designing one myself but, well, have no experience in that field and don't know where could I manufacture it...

Would be very expensive but I've got a few people that would definitely buy something like that.

I keep repeating myself, it's just because that's my dream case.
 

amar92

Chassis Packer
Feb 20, 2024
13
24
Exactly Sift, completely agree.

What I would add is 15 mm more width to accommodate a 155-160 CPU Cooler. That could probably add the option to install a 120mm fan in the back, and maybe one in the front like in the McPrue Apollo S v3.0

That would be the perfect case for me, personally.

Right now I'm running a 7950X3D and RTX 4090 and my temps are pretty amazing in the C4 v1.

I have to admit that I dream about the same case but being able to fit something like the upcoming Thermalright Royal Pretor 130..

Just imagine it :

ITX/MATX, CPU Cooler 155-160mm, 3 Slot GPU + 140x25 Fans, 120mm rear plus eventually a 120mm front (would have to be a front grille or mesh in the front...

All in about 17,5L, would just have to add about 1,5-2 cm in all directions.

Yes it would be a bit bigger, but would we really notice it that much? It isn't 25-30 L..

Wouldn't that be the perfect no compromise SFF case?

I was even thinking of designing one myself but, well, have no experience in that field and don't know where could I manufacture it...

Would be very expensive but I've got a few people that would definitely buy something like that.

I keep repeating myself, it's just because that's my dream case.
I think everything that I want is already available, except the GPU air duct/anti sag if I'm not mistaken - McPrue Apollo SE v2

I will be ordering one the next time they have them in stock, which should be in a couple of days, and I'll report here.

It's 17.4 L - Cooler up to 160mm, GPU length 342mm, GPU height 70 (+140 slim fans) or 3-slot + 25mm fans, rear 120mm fan, front 140mm.

So basically you can mount a Peerless Assassin 140, D15S with an rear intake 120mm, and exhaust it with a 140mm side and 140mm front fan (also GPU exhaust) - should be pretty great.

Can't wait to get it, and report here.

Yes, it's expensive, but there is nothing like it on the market right now, and the build quality is allegedly very premium.

Anyone looking for a C4 v1 in a couple of weeks? LOL