@Valantar
I get where you're coming from, but honestly I just would question the value of a spreadsheet of data that you essentially might not be able to trust anything about.
And the logistics of keeping it up to date may involve physically contacting sellers, constantly, and hoping they are accurately conveying the precise details of products.
It's just a really tall ask.
I seriously applaud anyone who attempts it and I will appreciate it if they do - but I'm still not sure I'd rely on it when putting money down on purchases.
I know in my own research of cases there and contacting sellers, I personally can't do it (nor do I want to) as it would be a nearly full time job trying to stay on top of it.
I get that this would be far too much, but that isn't what I'm suggesting either - all I'm saying is that it ought not to be too much work to collect a simple set of data (like the one I suggested above) which might then lead interested people to research the right cases in the first place, rather than looking at dozens of dead ends. IMO, motherboard standard (ITX, mATX, ATX, PIO?), PSU size (ATX, SFX, 1U, Flex-ATX, external/DC-DC, etc.), GPU support (full-size, ITX, LP, single slot, none), layout ("classic"/riserless, sandwich, console-style, etc.), and perhaps case material ought to be sufficient. Approximate size in litres would probably be a good addition, despite potential inaccuracy. It sounds unlikely to me that a given case is likely to change these characteristics between revisions, and my impression from people asking about cases is that these are the most important characteristics for starting the search for a case. It's not like searching for a case on Taobao is for the faint of heart anyhow, so the risk of misleading someone due to outdated data sounds minimal.
It sounds like you're thinking of a far more comprehensive database containing measurements, clearances, ventilation, cooler support, colors, etc., which would of course be amazing, but as you say, a full time job (at least!) to maintain. And, frankly, unnecessary.
IMO, my suggestion wouldn't be much harder to implement than agreeing on a standardized set of info and formatting of said info in this thread for any new case posted, which could then be added to the "master post" through a simple quote. That method does lose the ability to sort the list by desired characteristics, of course, but would be extremely simple to implement and maintain.
I.e. someone posting of a new case they found would say
randomuser said:
Hey, look at this cool case I found! Really love the design, and the front vents are cool.
[Perhaps a picture or three?]
Brand / model: XYZ-case 123
Mobo: ITX
PSU: SFX
GPU: Full size
Layout: Console
Volume: 3.141592 litres
Taobao link: fjadsklhfdskjlahufieanjlfhesuial
Instead of the current
randomuser2 said:
Hey, look at this cool new case I found, XYZ-case 123! Really love the design, and the front vents are cool. Link here: fhdjaklfhdsauuilfdshajklfheiu
To me, this is a low-effort, common-sense solution to ... well, not a problem, but something that has a lot of potential for improvement.