After a whole lot of profanity and testing I have narrowed the issue down to the 5700G not liking my Alienware AW3821DW display. If I power the machine on with a fully installed and configured OS it will happily boot into Windows and function completely fine. I took the machine to a spare TV in the house and it works as you would expect. Why I had no such issues with the 3200G, I have no idea. I have managed to make it into the BIOS once on both HDMI and DP via 5700G so I know it will occasionally work but it's on the order of maybe 5% of the time or less. Even restarting into UEFI settings from Windows and touching nothing just results in a black screen.
To further clarify how I discovered this - One of the few times it actually initialized correctly and booted all the way into my Windows install with the 5700G I noticed the graphics driver that was previously installed (for the 3200G) was not working and Windows had reverted to a basic display adapter. I downloaded and installed the correct driver for the 5700G and from that point it works fine as soon as drivers load. Getting anything before that is exceedingly rare but does occasionally happen.
User on reddit suggested it may be a UEFI GOP issue with Cezanne and some displays, based on quick google I agree this seems likely. This seems like something that should be fixable, and those with multiple monitors around will have an easier time. I gave away my extra monitors during the early WFH rush so don't have a lot of test ability compared to the before.
To further clarify how I discovered this - One of the few times it actually initialized correctly and booted all the way into my Windows install with the 5700G I noticed the graphics driver that was previously installed (for the 3200G) was not working and Windows had reverted to a basic display adapter. I downloaded and installed the correct driver for the 5700G and from that point it works fine as soon as drivers load. Getting anything before that is exceedingly rare but does occasionally happen.
User on reddit suggested it may be a UEFI GOP issue with Cezanne and some displays, based on quick google I agree this seems likely. This seems like something that should be fixable, and those with multiple monitors around will have an easier time. I gave away my extra monitors during the early WFH rush so don't have a lot of test ability compared to the before.