So I originally bought the LZ7 XTD together with a Prolimatech Ultra Sleek Vortex from Overclockers. But since I was dissatisfied with the noise levels, I decided to mess around with it to figure out how to make it quieter. Here are my thoughts:
Prolimatech Ultra Sleek Vortex:
- It's mostly quiet, but has a high-pitched, whirry "whine" (even at low speeds) which is very annoying to me.
- Do not buy the Prolimatech Static Booster for this fan. It won't fit in the case!
- You can't mount the LZ7 fan grille inside the case, since the grills will touch the fan blades, unless you use a washer.
- The LZ7 fan grille actually makes this fan noticably louder than it should be. I'm not an acoustical expert, but my guess is that the circular "center piece" of this grille causes some turbulence, maybe.
- I tried replacing the LZ7 fan grille with a Noctua FG-12, which doesn't have the same noisy effect as the default grille.
Cryorig XT140:
- On the upside, it does look cooler than the Prolimatech.
- I was hoping that this one will sound better, but no. It has the same noise, but somewhat even more pronounced.
- Also has trouble mounting the grille inside the case.
- It also exhibits the same effect that I observed regarding the two grilles with the Prolimatech: the LZ7 grille made it more noisy, the FG-12 was OK.
Nocuta NF-A12x15:
- I really wanted to like this one, since I'm quite happy with the other Noctua fans (NF-A9) that I use inside the case.
- This fan does not show the same whirr as the other two, but it has a much more "airplane-like" sound. This might be somewhat less annoying for some people, but it makes the fan louder than the previous two, especially at higher speeds.
- This fan allows you to mount the grille inside the case without the fan blades touching it.
- The choice of grille doesn't affect the loudness of this one. It was loud either way.
So, after the experiment, I went back to using the Prolimatech fan with the Noctua FG-12 grille. I added a few washers between it and the grille which allowed me to mount both of them on the inside. It barely fits, but fits. I will probably return the other fans to the shop, unless I find some sort of other use for them.
Some final notes:
If you listen to any kind of music, it will drown out the noise coming from either of the 3 fans. The same thing is true if you are in a noisy environment, so if you live in a city and you leave the windows open, the noise of the street will likely make the fan noise unnoticable. So, all in all, this is probably not worth obsessing about as much as I have. However if you're sitting in a quiet room and you don't listen to music the whole day, these fans do contribute to the overall noise of the computer.
Finally, I ended up setting the motherboard to just turn OFF the Prolimatech on lower temperatures. It will of course spin up under serious loads which does help cool the system under these circumstances. But it has barely any impact when the system is idle.
I hope someone will find this helpful. Have a nice day everyone!