Sorry, it's a bit unrelated but my package seems stuck a bit and hoped for an opinion. Tracking number says this as last info. Anyone getting similar?
2018-12-22 08:10 UNITED KINGDOM,COVENTRY PARCELFORCE ,Send item abroad (EDI-received)
This is great information, all in one post!A stock U9S should be compared to a stock C14S. If U9S is double-fanned, then C14S can also be double-fanned too.
The general data seems to suggest that C14S has better thermal performance. C14S is 820g, 6 heatpipes and stock fan moves 140 m3/min max vs U9S' 524g + 5 heatpipes + 80 m3/min max.
Example reviews saying C14S > U9S:-
http://www.relaxedtech.com/reviews/noctua/nh-u9s/4
https://www.guru3d.com/articles_pages/noctua_nh_c14s_low_profile_cpu_cooler_review,8.html
https://www.tweaktown.com/reviews/7284/noctua-nh-c14s-style-cpu-cooler-review/index6.html
But then, there are some reviews saying U9S > C14S:-
https://www.overclock3d.net/reviews/cases_cooling/cpu_air_cooler_mega_test/39
Additionally, Noctua itself says U9S can handle 215W but the C14S can handle only 190W. Both coolers are rated as ''compatible with certain restrictions''.
https://noctua.at/en/cpu/Intel_Core_i9-9900K
I think, for most situations, C14S will perform thermally better. But in some cases with some airflow arrangement, U9S will be better. However, if you wish to truly max out an i9 9900K, perhaps neither are very suitable. But, if you have to choose between the two, then you will have to actually buy both and try them inside a DA2.
Since DA2's general internal layout is similar to M1, I suggest you might go through the M1 thread to look for hint. I did that myself a few months ago as there are many people using C14/C14S/U9S inside a M1. My general feeling and memory is that, if the airflow is managed well, C14/C14S edges out U9S slightly thermally.
Of course, there are other factors to consider. Eg C14S is so huge that it blocks your access to the motherboard. It might have memory height limitation. But, it blows air down onto the motherboard and cools it. This factor may (or may not) become important, especially when the motherboard is inside a small (SFF) case where the internal is usually densely packed, thus limiting the establishment of clear airflow path(s). The smaller number of case fans of a SFF case does not help either.
Anyway, whether you try both or either one of them, I look forward to read your result.
In the meantime, here is yet another build floating out there:
https://www.reddit.com/r/sffpc/comments/aaxcax/my_streamcom_da2_build/
Ive decided... I'm gonna assemble my rig in a cardboard box. I dont even know if the parts work.
Another very recent build. It was written in Chinese but there are a lot of pics. Unfortunately, the focus is not the DA2 but the entire build. So, description of the DA2 is not detailed.
https://www.chiphell.com/thread-1943579-1-1.html
He is using 9900K + Corsair H115i + 2080FE. He planned to use a 92mm fan on the case rear but he discovered the 280mm rad does not leave enough space for it. He mentioned that he would rather have a 240 + rear 92mm fan (vs his 280) because his 280 is not cooling the 9900K too satisfactorily.
For numbers, the CPU is 87C (CPU-Z Benchmark test) and 82-91C (Intel XTU).
But his pic shows his DA2 is positioned with one side against a wall and so I suspect this might, sort of, blocking one half of the case ventilation in and out.
My DA2 arrived yesterday from QuietPC UK, but I was too jet lagged after 27h of travel and just opened it now, it is part 49/500 of the 18YB-09FA batch and yes, motherboard standoffs are present, hope this reassures a bit the ones that were worried.
.....
Now on to test the build on my BC1 Mini bench that also arrived today
.....
I build a lot of ITX systems to decided to get the BC1 mini and test the HW for the DA2 build on it first, it's a great bench have to say.So, you are building 2 systems at the same time? One with DA2 and one with BC1 Mini?
Looking forward to see both builds!
I have just finished building mine on a BC1 Mini Silver (which is documented in the Build Logs section, look for it if you are interested).
I have set my eyes on a DA2 for the next build (which will not be for myself but for my buddy).
I build a lot of ITX systems to decided to get the BC1 mini and test the HW for the DA2 build on it first, it's a great bench have to say.
.....
Uhm, I've only done a handful of builds in the past, but that much thermal paste is way off, isn't it?Another very recent build. It was written in Chinese but there are a lot of pics. Unfortunately, the focus is not the DA2 but the entire build. So, description of the DA2 is not detailed.
https://www.chiphell.com/thread-1943579-1-1.html
He is using 9900K + Corsair H115i + 2080FE. He planned to use a 92mm fan on the case rear but he discovered the 280mm rad does not leave enough space for it. He mentioned that he would rather have a 240 + rear 92mm fan (vs his 280) because his 280 is not cooling the 9900K too satisfactorily.
For numbers, the CPU is 87C (CPU-Z Benchmark test) and 82-91C (Intel XTU).
But his pic shows his DA2 is positioned with one side against a wall and so I suspect this might, sort of, blocking one half of the case ventilation in and out.