-
Save 15% on ALL SFF Network merch, until Dec 31st! Use code SFF2024 at checkout. Click here!
Prebuilt [SFFn] ASRock's DeskMini A300 - Finally!
- Thread starter confusis
- Start date
but dust gets sucked in by the vent when running much more than turned off i guess.
(german is my main language, used google translator help)
@rubicoin
Very good made ! Removing grill is good choice.
I think about to drill all holes above cooler up to 5mm. Described it here --> #491.
Or remove grill completly, as you did.
It is not much more dust, cause the fan rotate much lower
Overall, you safe wattage and noise.
Asrock or AMD coolers rotate with ~2000 rpm at office usage, +2,5 Watt !?
my Noctua NF-F12 PWM, 120mm ~480rpm, only 0,6 Watt maximum.
Dust is no problem, my first A300 was running ~5 months, opened it last week to test new RAM for my second A300.
There was very little dust inside, most of it stuck on my copper.
Bought another Noctuas very cheap, second hand, for my second A300 and 1 reserve
Meanwhile, the fan is only weighted with the weight of the 4 long screws so that it does not fly away.
I'll screw it to the housing or tie it with a cord.
For me it's not about making the device as small as possible.
I want it to be very quiet and energy efficient.
For USB-2.0 expansion used Audio hole.
This makes it much easier to open the device. For later cleaning
@rubicoin
Very good made ! Removing grill is good choice.
I think about to drill all holes above cooler up to 5mm. Described it here --> #491.
Or remove grill completly, as you did.
It is not much more dust, cause the fan rotate much lower
Overall, you safe wattage and noise.
Asrock or AMD coolers rotate with ~2000 rpm at office usage, +2,5 Watt !?
my Noctua NF-F12 PWM, 120mm ~480rpm, only 0,6 Watt maximum.
Dust is no problem, my first A300 was running ~5 months, opened it last week to test new RAM for my second A300.
There was very little dust inside, most of it stuck on my copper.
Bought another Noctuas very cheap, second hand, for my second A300 and 1 reserve
Meanwhile, the fan is only weighted with the weight of the 4 long screws so that it does not fly away.
I'll screw it to the housing or tie it with a cord.
For me it's not about making the device as small as possible.
I want it to be very quiet and energy efficient.
For USB-2.0 expansion used Audio hole.
This makes it much easier to open the device. For later cleaning
Last edited:
Yes, Ryzen 3400G and BIOS 3.51.
Random black screen for 1 second. Happens once or twice day, sometimes after hours of ontime.
My Ranking:
Nr.1
G.Skill RipJaws SO-DIMM 8GB, DDR4-3200, CL18-18-18-43 (F4-3200C18S-8GRS) <-- my second A300 use this
G.Skill RipJaws SO-DIMM Kit 16GB, DDR4-3200, CL18-18-18-43 (F4-3200C18D-16GRS)
Nr.2
G.Skill RipJaws SO-DIMM 8GB, DDR4-3000, CL16-18-18-43 (F4-3000C16S-8GRS)
G.Skill RipJaws SO-DIMM Kit 16GB, DDR4-3000, CL16-18-18-43 (F4-3000C16D-16GRS) <-- most popular
Nr.3
Kingston HyperX Impact SO-DIMM Kit 16GB, DDR4-2933, CL17-19-19 (HX429S17IB2K2/16) <-- my first A300 use this
(Nr.4)
G.Skill RipJaws SO-DIMM 8GB, DDR4-3200, CL16-18-18-43 (F4-3200C16S-8GRS) <-- fastest but very expensive
Parts:
my 1st A300 (~5 months old, with 2400G)
my 2nd A300 (~1 month old, with 3400G)
Benchmark (without Core Performance Boost):
my 2400G with 2933, CL17 --> Bench 90.4%
my 2400G with 3200, CL18 --> Bench 93.6%
---------------------------------------------------------------------
my 3400G with 2933, CL17 --> Bench 91,8%
--> Popular components in PC builds with the Asrock A300M-STX Motherboard
Nr.1
G.Skill RipJaws SO-DIMM 8GB, DDR4-3200, CL18-18-18-43 (F4-3200C18S-8GRS) <-- my second A300 use this
G.Skill RipJaws SO-DIMM Kit 16GB, DDR4-3200, CL18-18-18-43 (F4-3200C18D-16GRS)
Nr.2
G.Skill RipJaws SO-DIMM 8GB, DDR4-3000, CL16-18-18-43 (F4-3000C16S-8GRS)
G.Skill RipJaws SO-DIMM Kit 16GB, DDR4-3000, CL16-18-18-43 (F4-3000C16D-16GRS) <-- most popular
Nr.3
Kingston HyperX Impact SO-DIMM Kit 16GB, DDR4-2933, CL17-19-19 (HX429S17IB2K2/16) <-- my first A300 use this
(Nr.4)
G.Skill RipJaws SO-DIMM 8GB, DDR4-3200, CL16-18-18-43 (F4-3200C16S-8GRS) <-- fastest but very expensive
Parts:
my 1st A300 (~5 months old, with 2400G)
my 2nd A300 (~1 month old, with 3400G)
Benchmark (without Core Performance Boost):
my 2400G with 2933, CL17 --> Bench 90.4%
my 2400G with 3200, CL18 --> Bench 93.6%
---------------------------------------------------------------------
my 3400G with 2933, CL17 --> Bench 91,8%
--> Popular components in PC builds with the Asrock A300M-STX Motherboard
Last edited:
Got my A300 & 3400G running with these:
1x Kit: G.Skill SO-DDR4 32GB PC3000 CL16 (2x16GB)
or if cheaper:
2x G.Skill SO-DDR4 16GB PC3000 CL16 (1x16GB)
These are near the price/performance sweetspot imho.
Works fine in a passively cooled Case at high temps.
32GB is more future proof, snappier because no swap file/partition needed.
1x Kit: G.Skill SO-DDR4 32GB PC3000 CL16 (2x16GB)
or if cheaper:
2x G.Skill SO-DDR4 16GB PC3000 CL16 (1x16GB)
These are near the price/performance sweetspot imho.
Works fine in a passively cooled Case at high temps.
32GB is more future proof, snappier because no swap file/partition needed.
It all depends
Generally:Always get two sticks
I would not get 2x4GB anymore
2x8GB vs 2x16GB depends on your need for capacity but also on whether you want Single-Rank or Dual-Rank sticks. 16GB sticks should mostly be dual-rank, 8GB sticks mostly single-rank. Consult the vendor documentation if in doubt.
Higher than 2933 is possible, but the A300 has limitations with regard to achievable speed, the limitations are
1) Only supports discrete 1.2V or 1.35V for DIMM voltage
2) SOC Voltage rail suffers from high vdroop on GPU load
3) Board limits appear to kick in faster for the same CPU / RAM combination than on some full size boards
One appears to be generally looking at 3333 to 3466 being possible, depending on whether single/dual rank, voltages, luck, BIOS and so forth
With regard to a recommendation for a certain product, the plain Crucial DDR4-3200 SO-DIMMs
a) are very likely based on E-Die, which is known to be a good performer
b) some of the few DDR4-3200 RAM sticks on the ASRock Memory QVL
c) are some of the cheapest SO-DIMMs around on a price / GB metric
d) play nicely with the A300 limitations, because unlike other DRAM ICs the Micron ICs don't need voltage far above 1.35V to reach their maximum
The downside is that they don't come with XMP profiles. That means you will manually have to make all the settings. If you are fine with that I believe these offer really good value for money at the moment - they should take manual timings almost as good as the GSkill kits at quite a bit less cost.
8GB: https://www.crucial.com/usa/en/ct8g4sfs832a / Kit: https://www.crucial.com/usa/en/ct2k8g4sfs832a
16GB: https://www.crucial.com/usa/en/ct16g4sfd832a / Kit: https://www.crucial.com/usa/en/ct2k16g4sfd832a <- This is what I run atm
If i had to make a selection now I would likely wait the couple days until Crucial officially unveils the new Ballistix line: https://www.crucial.com/usa/en/gaming-memory and check whether the new Ballistix SO-DIMMs look like good value - if not take the plain Crucial 3200 RAM
Is the Noctua NH-L9A-AM4 able to cool a 3400G in the A300 "quietly"? If there is a silent fan profile in the BIOS, and any "turbo boosting" is disabled on the 3400G, what is the max rpm of the Noctua fan when the CPU is under stress? I have tried to look for some youtube videos where people are using the L9A and slim fan, but I don't see any noise recordings.
There are "Silent" Profiles in the BIOS, but I don't think anything that fits within the A300 case will be able to cool a 3400G inaudibly if you throw a severe workload at it, even with Core Performance Boost disabled. y-cruncher N64 will happily cause my 2400G (CBP disabled) to draw 65+ W according to Ryzen Master and it will throttle even below base clock, while at the same time still driving the CPU to 60+ C° over ambient all while the Noctua 92x25mm on a Jonsbo HP-400 heatsink is whirling quite audibly away at at it's max of 1800RPM not being able to stop temps from rising. If you want it to stay mostly silent at even the most stressful loads while still maintaining healthy temperatures you will have to underclock it to below base clock.
General productivity, running some VMs, leisure use, fan can be set to be mostly inaudible even with stock cooler. 3D gaming you should expect noise. If you go for the L9A and you want the lowest RPMs, consider a 25mm fan like @Wesley88 above, don't have to chop up the case right away.
Someone made AIDA-CPU-Stability-Test at 28.04.2019 (left Picture).
2400G + Noctua NH-L9a-AM4.
Made with my first A300 at 13.10.2019 (right Picture).
2400G +Noctua NF-F12 PWM, 120mm + Jonsbo HP-400 + Copper-drain.
With Manual-Fan-Setting i was able to reduce to 484 rpm, 43 degree.
CPU Minium 43 is good enough, i think lower no need or ?
As you can see the Noctua NF-F12 PWM, 120mm cool the Motherboard and M.2 SSD much better.
Because the 120mm Fan air flows through the entire housing.
Soon i test it with my second machine (3400G).
~24°C room temp.
2400G + Noctua NH-L9a-AM4.
Made with my first A300 at 13.10.2019 (right Picture).
2400G +Noctua NF-F12 PWM, 120mm + Jonsbo HP-400 + Copper-drain.
With Manual-Fan-Setting i was able to reduce to 484 rpm, 43 degree.
CPU Minium 43 is good enough, i think lower no need or ?
As you can see the Noctua NF-F12 PWM, 120mm cool the Motherboard and M.2 SSD much better.
Because the 120mm Fan air flows through the entire housing.
Soon i test it with my second machine (3400G).
~24°C room temp.
Last edited:
3200G (≠ 3400G) here, with the boxed Wraith Stealth. I've posted my fan control settings in this thread.
Whenever it's about to go idle I (automatically) put mine to transcoding, virtually 24/7, for months now. Which kinda says what I think about the VRM temps, and underutilized processing power.
The fan spins at about 1450 rpm – wattage is below 2.4W @m4758406, details in my previous posts –, the cpu sits at 62°C (20°C room temp). Even if it hit 80°C I wouldn't be concerned.
Don't give into over-engineering! Which also is a waste.
Goes for the copper air shroud as well, which is overkill and the copper will influence temperatures less than marginally. A crown made of hard paper or strapping tape will do, too. (I don't use one, see above for temps.)
--
The bolts are DIN 7991 M3 (M3×10, but rather 6 or 8). I'd expect every German mechanic, technician, or mechanical engineer to properly express such things. ;-)
(“Case bolts” usually are UNC 6-32.)
--
My guess is Asrock won't support any AMD 4000G in a A300. Would be nice, though.
And, Asrock's new SFF model caters to a less demanding crowd than the A300 imho.
--
Did anyone connect a desktop hdd drive (3.5" drive) to the A300?
I've still some data on one to be uploaded, and like to avoid buying an external enclosure if possible. I am aware consumer 2.5" drives suck less power (sth. like 1W vs 6W when busy) and am worried the tiny SATA connector won't be able to sustain powering the bigger drive.
Whenever it's about to go idle I (automatically) put mine to transcoding, virtually 24/7, for months now. Which kinda says what I think about the VRM temps, and underutilized processing power.
The fan spins at about 1450 rpm – wattage is below 2.4W @m4758406, details in my previous posts –, the cpu sits at 62°C (20°C room temp). Even if it hit 80°C I wouldn't be concerned.
Don't give into over-engineering! Which also is a waste.
Goes for the copper air shroud as well, which is overkill and the copper will influence temperatures less than marginally. A crown made of hard paper or strapping tape will do, too. (I don't use one, see above for temps.)
--
The bolts are DIN 7991 M3 (M3×10, but rather 6 or 8). I'd expect every German mechanic, technician, or mechanical engineer to properly express such things. ;-)
(“Case bolts” usually are UNC 6-32.)
--
My guess is Asrock won't support any AMD 4000G in a A300. Would be nice, though.
And, Asrock's new SFF model caters to a less demanding crowd than the A300 imho.
--
Did anyone connect a desktop hdd drive (3.5" drive) to the A300?I've still some data on one to be uploaded, and like to avoid buying an external enclosure if possible. I am aware consumer 2.5" drives suck less power (sth. like 1W vs 6W when busy) and am worried the tiny SATA connector won't be able to sustain powering the bigger drive.
Last edited:
@LostEnergy
I am still waiting for this cable, ordered it some months ago.
I have some old Western Digital 3,5" Desktop Hard Drives and IDE-SATA-Converter-Cable.
[TD valign="top"]
[/TD]
[TD valign="top"]
[/TD]
Later i can tell you if it works.
Today i read about my WD2500JB, it need 21,4 Watt for spinup ?
I am still waiting for this cable, ordered it some months ago.
I have some old Western Digital 3,5" Desktop Hard Drives and IDE-SATA-Converter-Cable.
| Quantity | 1 | 1 | 1 | 3 | |
| WD800BB | WD2500BB | WD5000AAKB | |||
| Rotational Speed | RPM (nominal) | 7200 | 7200 | 7200 | 7200 |
| Buffer Size | MB | 2 | 2 | 8 | 16 |
| Average Latency | ms (nominal) | 4,2 | 4,2 | 4,2 | |
| Start/Stop Cycles | minimum | 50000 | 50000 | ||
| Read Seek Time | ms | 8,9 | 8,9 | 8,9 | |
| Write Seek Time | ms (average) | 10,9 | 10,9 | 10,9 | |
| Track-To-Track Seek Time | ms (average) | 2 | 2 | 2 | |
| Full Stroke Seek | ms (average) | 21 | 21 | 21 | |
| Formatted Capacity | MB | 80,026 | 250,059 | 250,059 | 500,107 |
| Capacity | GB | 80 | 250 | 250 | 500 |
| Interface | EIDE MB/s | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
| User Sectors Per Drive | 156,301,488 | 488,397,168 | 488,397,168 | 976,773,168 | |
| Spinup | Watts | 21,4 | |||
| Seek | Watts | 12,5 | |||
| Watts | 8 | 8,6 | 8,8 | 8,77 | |
| Idle | Watts | 7,25 | 8,1 | 8,3 | 8,4 |
| Standby | Watts | 1,2 | 1,1 | 1,2 | 0,97 |
| Sleep | Watts | 0,5 | 1 | 0,7 | 0,97 |
[TD valign="top"]
| WD2500JB |
[TD valign="top"]
| Read/Write |
Today i read about my WD2500JB, it need 21,4 Watt for spinup ?
Last edited:
You could just refer to the manual though:
"These two SATA3 connectors support SATA data cables for internal storage devices with up to 6.0 Gb/s data transfer rate. *The SATA3 connectors support 2.5-inch hard drive (+5V) and do not support 3.5-inch hard drive (+12V)"
"These two SATA3 connectors support SATA data cables for internal storage devices with up to 6.0 Gb/s data transfer rate. *The SATA3 connectors support 2.5-inch hard drive (+5V) and do not support 3.5-inch hard drive (+12V)"
Bit of a bummer, but given that using a 3.5" drive with an A300 requires some sort of hacky implementation to begin with it should be relatively simple to run a +12V line into the SATA power connector from an external source. Depends if the stock power cables are the crimp pin type or the squeeze-the-wires-into-the-connector type, but either way it should be possible if one really wanted to do it. Or I guess one could use a SATA power splitter and just solder a wire into the 12V wire on that (that would also work on the cable m47 linked above).
There's been changes in the standards, such as dropping the +3.3V line. Some drives might as well run off +5V alone. Might try it with my HGST He8 Ultrastar eventually, though its datasheet says both are required. I wouldn't be super surprised if they connected the +12V anyway, hence me asking. Worst case the drive won't spin up then.
Similar threads
