Cooling Reviews

Scythe Big Shuriken 2 Rev B – Big Name for a Small Cooler

One of the standard CPU cooler options when it comes to building a SFF system is the the Scythe Big Shuriken 2, and this comes as no surprise: the cooler has been around for a while. The low-profile nature of the otherwise generously-sized design means it can fit in a plethora of enclosures that are otherwise height-restrictive above the motherboard, all while providing performance characteristics that are closer to those of large tower-style coolers.

A recent revision of the Big Shuriken 2 – Rev B – added support for LGA2011 and 2011 V3 sockets. As such, we’re taking advantage of this minor refresh to see if the Big Shuriken 2 still holds its own in the SFF CPU cooler battle. Featuring 5 copper heatpipes and a slim 120mm fan, the Big Shuriken 2 is certainly one of the larger SFF orientated coolers on the market – but with its size comes the ability to cope with higher wattage processors.

About Scythe

From Scythe’s Website:

Selected PC Parts for DIY PC Experts

Scythe Co., Ltd., (Registered and incorporated in Tokyo Japan) originally started its business operation in Japan’s famous “Akihabara Electric Town” located in the metropolitan Tokyo, where visitors can find a variety of products from the latest computer parts to the world’s most advanced high-tech electric devices.

Sythe Co., Ltd., began its operation and business since November, 2002 as a distributor and the manufacturer of passive and low-noise PC parts.  Since then, the company has established the R&D facility in Taiwan & China for production and quality control, and the USA office (in Los Angeles, California) & European office (in Hamburg, Germany) for customer care and sales support.

At Scythe, we believe that the best ideas for product come simply from knowing customers’ needs and their expectations.  Based on this philosophy, the PC enthusiasts working at Scythe know what to develop because that is exactly what we would like to have for ourselves too!  We offer products with 100% quality assurance and total pride, and if the product has the Scythe name on it, you can rest assure that its quality will be up to the “Zero Tolerance” standards!

The Big Shuriken 2 Rev B

HEATSINK SPECIFICATION
Dimension ( with fan ) L125 mm x W135 mm x H58 mm
Weight ( with fan ) 410 g
Weight ( without fan ) 312 g
Heat pipes 6mm  copper heatpipe x 5
Fin Material Aluminium
Fin Count 80 pcs
Copper Base Copper nickel plated
RAM Height Limit 39 mm
TDP Not specified
 Replaceable Fan? Yes
FAN SPECIFICATION
Dimension L120 mm x W120 mm x H12 mm
Weight 89 g
Rated Speed 500 ~ 2000 RPM ±10 %
Noise Level 9.32 – 33.67 dBA
Air Flow 12.13 – 45.47 CFM
Air Pressure 0.11 – 1.35 mmH2O
Ampere 0.19 A

The cooler has compatibility with AMD sockets AM2, AM2+, AM3, AM3+, FM1, FM2 and FM2+ (as well as some variants of Socket 1207). On the Intel side, compatibility is with sockets 1150, 1151, 1155 and 1156, as well as LGA775, LGA2011 and LGA2011 V3.

Unboxing

Shuriken (13)

The Scythe Big Shuriken 2 Rev B comes in what can only be described as a “typically-Scythe” styled box (whether or not that’s a good thing, we’ll leave to the personal taste of the user!). The marketing and specifications are listed in both English and Japanese, a reflection of the company’s Japanese heritage. And the box itself is in full color, and is composed of decent quality cardboard – a welcome fact given the distance these coolers often travel from the factory floor to the home.

Shuriken (3)

On one side, we see the fan specifications and a simple graphic illustrating the top-down airflow design. The fan included with this cooler is one of Scythe’s slim (12mm thick!) 120mm fans, which is a major contributor to the reduction in overall height.

Shuriken (2)

The rear of the box lists all the specifications of the cooler in 6 languages, as well a few token warnings (sharp edges, read the manual, etc). Hopefully you have a magnifying glass handy!

Shuriken (1)

The remaining side  shows a packing list, listing all the parts and components included with the cooler. We wish more components included this.

Shuriken (5) Shuriken (6)

Opening up the box, we immediately begin to  look at the Big Shuriken 2 Rev B itself. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the first thing that grabs our attention is the slim fan atop the cooler. This fan is rated to spin between 500 and 2000 RPM, and Scythe claims 9.32 – 33.67 dbA noise output for this fan across that range. That said, I’ve found that it’s not always the loudness of the fan, but the characteristics of the noise it emits, that make a difference. I’ll speak towards this more qualitative measure later on.

Shuriken (8) Shuriken (9)

Flipping the cooler over, we see that the base is nickel plated copper. A clean reflection with no discernible distortion is indicative of good quality.

Shuriken (7)

Turning the cooler over once again, and pulling off the fan, we see that the 80 aluminium fins composing the heatsink are pretty densely packed, with each of the heatpipe ends passing through them and poking out of the sides. The centre of each heatpipe (five total) passes through the base of the cooler.

Shuriken (4)

Finally, included in the box is a large selection of parts, including a backplate to mount the cooler. Scythe also includes a single dose of Scythe thermal compound – which I’m not a big fan of, since if you mess up while mounting, or wish to move it to a new system, means that you’ll have to purchase additional paste separately. Either of those scenarios is all but inevitable for most builders.

Shuriken (10)

As you can see, even with the 120mm fan, this cooler is still relatively small!

Hardware Compatibility

Shuriken (11)Shuriken (12)

Mounted on our test dummy board, you can see the Big Shuriken does limit the height of RAM. That said, standard RAM height (excluding heatspreaders that go beyond the edge of the PCB) will still fit, which is nice. No other components are blocked by the cooler in our own testing, but it has been noted that the PCIe x16 slot may be blocked on some M-ITX boards. As always, you’ll simply have to check to see if this would affect your own build configuration.

Cooling Performance

The SFFN test bench currently includes the following hardware:

  • Gigabyte 970-D3P Motherboard
  • Phenom II 555BE @ 3.2GHz
  • 8GB Crucial DDR3-1600 Value RAM (single DIMM)
  • Hitachi 60gb 2.5″ 5400RPM SATA HDD (temporary!)
  • Gigabyte R7-360
  • Thermal Master 420W Power Supply
  • Aluminium Test Bench Chassis

To test this cooler, we relied on relatively simple testing methodologies. Using Deepcool Z3 thermal paste (a budget, but decent performing, paste), we mounted the Scythe Big Shuriken 2 Rev B to our 89w AMD Phenom.

To retrieve idle temps, we booted up Windows, loaded HW Monitor and left the system to idle for 10 minutes. The hottest core was recorded at that time.

To load the CPU, we ran Prime95 Blend, with 2 threads (as our CPU is a dual core part). After 20 minutes of load, we once again took the hottest CPU core at that time.

Finally, we repeated this test while having the CPU fan plugged directly into 12v, waited 10 minutes under load, and recorded the hottest core.

We also measured ambient temperatures and converted all results to Delta T (change from ambient) to normalize the results. The fans were run at ‘Normal’ fan control mode in our motherboard’s BIOS.

Temperatures

Looking at the results, we see that the Big Shuriken 2 Rev B certainly holds its ground with the bigger coolers, as it is only outplayed by the Noctua NH-D15, and the Scythe Ninja 4. That’s not terribly surprising, considering the significant increase in fins, and the mass of both those products.

During testing, the fan was quiet, with no notable harshness. A significant upgrade over stock coolers!

Final Thoughts

There’s a reason the Big Shuriken 2 and its predecessors have been a stalwart of the SFF world for so long – fantastic performance in a low profile form ain’t easy, but this cooler manages to provide both.

The cooler performs well, supports most modern sockets, and is upgradeable insofar that a standard 120mm fan can be fitted to the cooler (as long as it has open sides). At a price point of $46, that’s a combination that addresses the needs of a large block of SFF enthusiasts, and leaves us wondering what sorts of builds would ever truly need the additional performance provided by larger coolers.

Pros:

Big 120mm fan.

Doesn’t block slots or hardware on our test board.

Supports most modern sockets.

Well built.

Fan is replaceable

Cons:

The slim fan has been noted in some cases to have an overheating hub.

Possible conflicts on some boards, but this is a given with most coolers.

 

This cooler is available for around US$45.99 from Amazon. 

Thoughts? Discuss them in the forum.

Review sample provided by eTonix Media PR on behalf of Scythe.

Here at SmallFormFactor.net we give manufacturers the ability to be part of the community. We offer a right to reply to hardware reviews. If a manufacturer responds, their comments will be posted here.