maybe that's a good thing haha
but crazy that the fan died so quickly.
-
Save 15% on ALL SFF Network merch, until Dec 31st! Use code SFF2024 at checkout. Click here!
Crosshair VIII Impact + M1 v6 = High Chipset temp
- Thread starter PizzaPino
- Start date
but crazy that the fan died so quickly.
Hey guys, I too have this motherboard. I saw there were many people with different X570 boards that had only 60c temperatures where as I was always at 72+c, so I did some investigating... (yeah, I took the board apart!)
It turns out that the thermal padding that ASUS is using is absolutely awful. What's happening is that the pads have a crazy amount of residue on them, and they compress really easily, maintaining their form once compressed. Over time (a few weeks after manufacturing probably), the thermal pads lost contact with the X570 chip! When I took my pads off, there was just a thick layer of pad residue touching the surface of the chip, as well as the shape of the chip engraved into the pad. The pad itself was not maintaining contact to the center of the X570 chip at all!
So I replaced it with Arctic 1.5mm thermal pad which is not squishy at all, is very low residue, and has a fairly high W/mK rating while being affordable.
... I booted up and after 10 minutes of browsing the web and playing WoW my chipset temperature is 55 celsius!
I proceeded to unplug BOTH of the fans. I don't think the chipset fan was doing anything for the chipset, and it was causing a bunch of dust build up inside the Q error code display thing due to it being set up as an intake that blew air into the display (???)
The VRM fan for whatever reason is set up as a VRM fan (dude, that crazy efficient VRM doesn't even need to touch the heatsink!), even though I think it should have been synced with the chipset fan because both fans are pushing air through the same metal chunky heatsink. I think one or both should have been set up in exhaust. I tried to flip them to exhaust but the fan blades clip the heatsink when upside down. Yikes.
I think my 240mm radiator fans working as an intake will blow enough cool air at the VRM/Chipset heatsink to keep it cool.
Alright, I finished my post, my chipset is at 58c. I think it'll top out at 70c without the fans but I suppose we'll see.
Update: It's been a full day of gaming and the max chipset temp is 63c.
Update 2: Alright so the AIO is definitely cooling the chipset well with the fans removed. Removing the fans allow the cool air from the AIO fans to reach the heatsink without getting blocked as much. Entertainingly, the hotter the CPU gets, the cooler the chipset gets because of the fan speed up. When my AIO fans are at 700 RPM, the chipset sits at around 63 celsius (68 celsius max over these past few days). When they increase to 1200 RPM, the chipset goes down to 58 celsius, and when they increase to 1800 RPM, the chipset goes all the way down to 53 celsius! Regardless, they are all very much under the safe temperature limit.
It turns out that the thermal padding that ASUS is using is absolutely awful. What's happening is that the pads have a crazy amount of residue on them, and they compress really easily, maintaining their form once compressed. Over time (a few weeks after manufacturing probably), the thermal pads lost contact with the X570 chip! When I took my pads off, there was just a thick layer of pad residue touching the surface of the chip, as well as the shape of the chip engraved into the pad. The pad itself was not maintaining contact to the center of the X570 chip at all!
So I replaced it with Arctic 1.5mm thermal pad which is not squishy at all, is very low residue, and has a fairly high W/mK rating while being affordable.
... I booted up and after 10 minutes of browsing the web and playing WoW my chipset temperature is 55 celsius!
I proceeded to unplug BOTH of the fans. I don't think the chipset fan was doing anything for the chipset, and it was causing a bunch of dust build up inside the Q error code display thing due to it being set up as an intake that blew air into the display (???)
The VRM fan for whatever reason is set up as a VRM fan (dude, that crazy efficient VRM doesn't even need to touch the heatsink!), even though I think it should have been synced with the chipset fan because both fans are pushing air through the same metal chunky heatsink. I think one or both should have been set up in exhaust. I tried to flip them to exhaust but the fan blades clip the heatsink when upside down. Yikes.
I think my 240mm radiator fans working as an intake will blow enough cool air at the VRM/Chipset heatsink to keep it cool.
Alright, I finished my post, my chipset is at 58c. I think it'll top out at 70c without the fans but I suppose we'll see.
Update: It's been a full day of gaming and the max chipset temp is 63c.
Update 2: Alright so the AIO is definitely cooling the chipset well with the fans removed. Removing the fans allow the cool air from the AIO fans to reach the heatsink without getting blocked as much. Entertainingly, the hotter the CPU gets, the cooler the chipset gets because of the fan speed up. When my AIO fans are at 700 RPM, the chipset sits at around 63 celsius (68 celsius max over these past few days). When they increase to 1200 RPM, the chipset goes down to 58 celsius, and when they increase to 1800 RPM, the chipset goes all the way down to 53 celsius! Regardless, they are all very much under the safe temperature limit.
Last edited:
HWiNFO (64) works great. It even reads my H100i Pro liquid temps and both fan speeds.
I have mine reorganized from the defaults, but this is what it looks like: https://share.adduono.com/HP1A.png
You can't see the chipset fan speed on mine only because I have it marked as "Ignored" in the BIOS (since I removed the fan, didn't want to show errors on boot) which hides it when querying the Nuvoton chip from programs too.
However, it does display it just fine if it is enabled and plugged in.
I think in BIOS/UEFI version 1201 ASUS has addressed the fan noise by defaulting the chipset fan to speeds based on VRM temperatures. I'm not sure if this is correct, but it is what I saw after updating my BIOS lol! This should make both the top and bottom fans run at about the same speed, which is MUCH quieter.
Honestly, this makes sense because their lack of thermal pad contact on the chipset meant the heatsink wasn't really doing anything for it in the first place.
Funny though, I don't think the VRM even needs to contact the heatsink either unless you're doing insane overclocking. (uh good luck on Ryzen 3xxx?)
So yeah, the heatsink and fans are both kinda pointless.
Last edited:
I just finish build in my Ncase M1 with ROG Strix X570-I Gaming and Ryzen 3900x. Everything is silent but PCH fan after 30 min. have around 5000-6000 RPM. Motherboards temparatute is around 40-45C. I have Corsair AIO 240 cooling and I have to put those fan and pump to Balanced mode in Icue software (before they are in quiet mode). After that I got lower RPM but still around 4600-5000RMP. Everything higher than 5000RPM is audibly. My Ryzen is OC to 4,25MHz and everything is cool and silent execept this fan. I was trying to change settings in Q-fan in BIOS but without success. My BIOS dont recognize CPU fan (because fans are attached on the cooler so cpu fan header is empty). I was trying change settings in BIOS with CHASIS fun... then optimization by BIOS...ignore PCH fan monitoring...but not succes. I touched my VRM shield but is not so hoot. I remove all usb from the back where is PCH fan to lower usb on motherboard. If I will manage get this fan around 4000RPM then is almost inaudible. MY build:
I just finish build in my Ncase M1 with ROG Strix X570-I Gaming and Ryzen 3900x. Everything is silent but PCH fan after 30 min. have around 5000-6000 RPM. Motherboards temparatute is around 40-45C. I have Corsair AIO 240 cooling and I have to put those fan and pump to Balanced mode in Icue software (before they are in quiet mode). After that I got lower RPM but still around 4600-5000RMP. Everything higher than 5000RPM is audibly. My Ryzen is OC to 4,25MHz and everything is cool and silent execept this fan. I was trying to change settings in Q-fan in BIOS but without success. My BIOS dont recognize CPU fan (because fans are attached on the cooler so cpu fan header is empty). I was trying change settings in BIOS with CHASIS fun... then optimization by BIOS...ignore PCH fan monitoring...but not succes. I touched my VRM shield but is not so hoot. I remove all usb from the back where is PCH fan to lower usb on motherboard. If I will manage get this fan around 4000RPM then is almost inaudible. MY build:
My IDLE temp are lower on asus X570-I Gaming (around 45C) but may PCH fan is between 5000-6000 RPM after one hour. I have Ryzen 3900x OC to 4,25MHz. What is your configuration and RPM of PCH fan?
I had the same motherboard X570i, built into the Ncase M1 v6.1. Anyway, I built myself a case very similar to the Ncase. I had the same problems with my fan spinning at 3750 all the time. It is quite annoying, so I put a 92mm Noctua pushing air into the case. On top of this, I deshrouded my aorus 1080ti xtreme and put 2 Noctuas 120mm on the card as exhaust. With the latest bios update, the pch fan is running at 1700. So things are O.K. now for me. If anybody would ask me what ITX board to buy, I would tell him to go with a B450 or X470, of course.
Regards
Leinel
Last edited:
I don't think so because it wasn't that bad.
Anyway, with the newest bios update, it's not spinning constantly anymore and is pretty quiet now.
