[SFFn] SilverStone's AR11 - Heatpipe Direct Contact Returns

Discussion in 'Hardware' started by confusis, Nov 7, 2018.

  1. confusis

    confusis John Morrison. Writer, Editor, Awesome Person.
    Thread Starter Site Staff SFF Workshop

    Heatpipe Direct Contact - buzzwords from a bygone era when heatsink technology hadn't quite reached the peak it is at now. However, there may still be performance to be gained from this technology - especially in smaller form factors where getting the heat to the cooling fins is of utmost priority - a heatsoaking solid baseplate may not be the best option.

    SilverStone has launched the Argon Series AR11 - a 47mm high heatsink with a blend of old and new technology. Let's see how it performs!

    Read more here.
     
    Hifihedgehog, Phuncz, Kooki and 4 others like this.
  2. Solo

    Solo Master of Cramming
    Silver Supporter

    Should've cloned the Gentle Typhoon blade array. Probably would have been a sick cooler.
     
  3. Nasp

    Nasp SFF Lingo Aficionado

    Will admit that I skimmed the review, but did you try with a 25mm thick Noctua fan?
     
  4. confusis

    confusis John Morrison. Writer, Editor, Awesome Person.
    Thread Starter Site Staff SFF Workshop

    @Nasp No I did not. Adding in a 25mm fan brings the height into the realms of much larger coolers - the NH-L9x65, and some 120mm slim fan coolers :)
     
  5. confusis

    confusis John Morrison. Writer, Editor, Awesome Person.
    Thread Starter Site Staff SFF Workshop

    Hey folks, some updates from @SilverStone - points that I missed and feel should be included;

    -I tested on a 54W CPU, (the highest wattage Intel chip I have to hand. Damn my i7-7700T's power friendliness!), so the results at higher wattages should be more pronounced
    -The NH-L9i will struggle a bit with 95W CPUs, unlike the AR11 which is rated for that wattage bracket
    -The C7 Cu is a heavier and more expensive cooler!

    Also to note;
    -Silverstone tested with the AR06's fan, and found the airflow insufficient at the 95W TDP level
     
    Phuncz and VegetableStu like this.
  6. SilverStone

    SilverStone Caliper Novice
    SilverStone

    el01, mantide, Hifihedgehog and 2 others like this.
  7. Mortis Angelus

    Mortis Angelus Airflow Optimizer
    Bronze Supporter

    Thanks for the review, @confusis !

    It is odd that a company well indoctrinated to the cooling scene would put an airflow fan, not a static pressure fan, onto a cooler at all. I mean, it is a pretty simple rule, never to put airflow fans onto anything with air resistance. :/

    But basically, with a Noctua fan, you get 4 degrees better temps than with a regular noctua nh-l9i, but at the cost of being thicker? Right?
     
    dealda, el01 and Phuncz like this.
  8. mantide

    mantide Trash Compacter

    Does this fit in deskmini?
     
  9. annasoh323

    annasoh323 Airflow Optimizer

    The dimensions, # of heatpipes, and the rated TDP seem to indicate that this is targeted straight at the C7 (Cu? Also, I'm comparing it to the C7 because I have one). It seems to stack up favorably well enough such that it's justifiable as an alternative to new shoppers, if not quite a "buy it now and replace all your C7's!" option. It seems like a nice, no-nonsense kit. Would be interested to see additional testing as well.
     
    el01 likes this.
  10. Skinz

    Skinz Caliper Novice

    Lack of Am4 seems rather odd going into 2019. It is the key thing making me ignore it over a C7 or L9a.
     
  11. rawsh

    rawsh Caliper Novice

    Looks like at it's trading blows with the x65 with a 15mm fan. Maybe removing the original fan and adding a A9 PWM on is the way to go for those taller cases then, as the AR11 would still be smaller than the l9x65 at 57 mm.
     
  12. Thehack

    Thehack SFF Guru
    Bronze Supporter Creator

    At 57mm, it is real close to Big Shuriken 2 and Reeven Brontes. Those would be better.