Low Profile CPU Cooler round up

Discussion in 'Hardware' started by IntoxicatedPuma, Apr 16, 2018.

  1. IntoxicatedPuma

    IntoxicatedPuma Customizer of Titles
    Thread Starter Site Staff Moderator Silver Supporter

    #1 IntoxicatedPuma, Apr 16, 2018
    Last edited: Apr 18, 2018
    This is still a work in progress but I wanted to share the results I have so far.

    I tested at two settings (3.5ghz & 4.0ghz) on the same system, and two different fan speeds (50% & 100%). In green you will find the temps at 100% fan speed, and the red is the additional temp when running at 50%.

    Here is my testing methodology:

    CPU is cleaned wtih Arctic thermal paste remover and purifier each time the cooler is removed. MX-4 paste was used for all tests and applied in the same fashion (a small pea amount in a short line).

    Ambient temperature monitored using a digital thermometer with an additional sensor placed above the intake fan. For ambient temperatures, I took the temperature recorded on the desk not by the test bench.

    HW Monitor and Prime 95 was the software used. 15 minutes of stress testing on Prime 95 with maximum temperature taken from HW Monitor.

    Test bench is an open air bench with Silverstone ST50F-P power supply, Asus B85M-Gamer board, Intel i5 4690k CPU, and 2x4g Kingston HyperX Savage DDR3 2133mhz. SSD was OCZ Trion TR150 240g. No external fans were used, and the PSU fan position was away from the motherboard.


    edit 4/18: Updated the charts and condensed to one, with tabs for the different clock speeds. Some coolers with specific fan configurations were added, 4.3ghz test results were added, Noctua NH-D9L & NH-U9S were added.

    A list of "coming soon" coolers:
    Arctic Freezer 11LP
    Arctic Alpine 11 GT
    Coolermaster V200 / Vortex 211P
    Gelid Slim Silence-I
    ID-Cooling IS-40
    ID-Cooling VC-45
    ID-Cooling DK-03 Halo
    InfiPlus i95
    InfiPlus i135T
    Jonsbo HP400
    Phanteks PH-TC90LS
    Scythe S950N
    Scythe Kozuti
    Silverstone AR05
    Silverstone AR09
    Silverstone AR10
    Thermaltake Slim X3
     
  2. Kmpkt

    Kmpkt Innovation through Miniaturization
    Gold Supporter KMPKT

    Awesome. Thanks for taking the time to do this @IntoxicatedPuma

    Also super interesting to see the C7 Cu outperforms the regular C7 by a mere degree on testing. Might explain why it isn't hitting the market through formal channels.
     
  3. IntoxicatedPuma

    IntoxicatedPuma Customizer of Titles
    Thread Starter Site Staff Moderator Silver Supporter

    I guess I should mention that KMPKT donated a large number of coolers to this effort, so a special thanks to him!
     
  4. VegetableStu

    VegetableStu SFF Guru

    the C7cu results o_o
    I remember someone mentioning the C7 had poor airflow within itself, is that the reason for this similar results on the copper edition? o_o
     
  5. IntoxicatedPuma

    IntoxicatedPuma Customizer of Titles
    Thread Starter Site Staff Moderator Silver Supporter

    I am unsure. I'm also working on a full review of the Cu so I will check some things out this week and find out more details.
     
  6. dumplinknet

    dumplinknet Airflow Optimizer

    That webpage doesn't pull up correctly for me. Can someone summarize it up for me? Where does the legendary LP53 sit in terms of the other coolers?
     
  7. Chrizz

    Chrizz Average Stuffer

    [​IMG]
     
  8. IntoxicatedPuma

    IntoxicatedPuma Customizer of Titles
    Thread Starter Site Staff Moderator Silver Supporter

    Summary: not in a legendary position. Its decent though.
     
  9. Thehack

    Thehack SFF Guru
    Bronze Supporter Creator

    The issue is this graph doesn't control for noise. So you don't know what is comparable with each other.

    Even more so it is not even overall sound dB but the sound signature. High frequency buzzy fans are perceived to be louder than low hums, yet they register lower on dB.

    But this review does provide us a very coarse snapshot of how we can see the maximum stock performance to be.
     
  10. IntoxicatedPuma

    IntoxicatedPuma Customizer of Titles
    Thread Starter Site Staff Moderator Silver Supporter

    Noise comparisons will come later. I have documented the speed the fans were running and will be recording sample clips of the coolers at different fan speeds. I do not plan to record dB ratings for the reason you mentioned, I'll just record noise in the same settings for all and let the listener decide, as noise is highly subjective.
     
    chyll2, Kwirek, SithLord and 4 others like this.
  11. Thehack

    Thehack SFF Guru
    Bronze Supporter Creator

    If you want to above an beyond, you can attach a frequency snapshot. Bad noise signatures will show as spikes on the snapshot.

    If you want to do a perceived dB level, I would take a solid recording and use a parametric equalizer that applies the perceived noise level curve then record the dB as a single value.

    Just some suggestions should you want to go into more depth.
     
  12. IntoxicatedPuma

    IntoxicatedPuma Customizer of Titles
    Thread Starter Site Staff Moderator Silver Supporter

    Great suggestions! I'll do the frequency snapshot for sure. It should be easy to do using Audacity.

    My goal eventually will be to provide as much data as possible to consumers using standardized methods. If it is possible some day to add an AMD Ryzen test bench I will try to do that as well.
     
  13. Thehack

    Thehack SFF Guru
    Bronze Supporter Creator

    If you are already recording two sets of samples, 50% and 100%, you can easily add in the perceived loudness dB and plot it vs temperature. It would then be possible to kind of approximate performance very well.

    If you want me to, I can organize the data for you if you can get me readings and recordings for 50%, 75% and 100%.

    Do you have a decent quality mic? Something like a blueball or audio Technica.
     
  14. IntoxicatedPuma

    IntoxicatedPuma Customizer of Titles
    Thread Starter Site Staff Moderator Silver Supporter

    I have a Zoom H1 and Rode VideoMicro, would those work? I'm not very skilled with Audio, usually I just get cheaper stuff that works well enough for me. I had a Blue Yeti but sold it last month...
     
  15. Thehack

    Thehack SFF Guru
    Bronze Supporter Creator

    Those seems okay. Give it a try. Compare the noise floor and the cooler sounds to see if it is sensitive enough.
     
    Soul_Est likes this.
  16. Untero

    Untero Average Stuffer

    Getting curious where 4-piped Titan NC-25 would take it's place in the chart..
     
  17. IntoxicatedPuma

    IntoxicatedPuma Customizer of Titles
    Thread Starter Site Staff Moderator Silver Supporter

    I also wondered this, but unfortunately you cannot buy Titan coolers in China. However, yesterday I received this from Japan:
    [​IMG]

    Like Ash in Pokemon, I will not stop until I have them all.
     
  18. Untero

    Untero Average Stuffer

    Whoa, that layout looks exactly like titan's one! Along with 46mm height and 130W max TDP it seems to be a Titan's twin!
     
  19. Thehack

    Thehack SFF Guru
    Bronze Supporter Creator

    Looks like so. There are many OEM coolers that companies rebrand.

    It looks better than C7 since there seems to be more contact between the heat pipes and the fins.
     
  20. dumplinknet

    dumplinknet Airflow Optimizer

    What is this? And what is the Titan cooler?